Loading market quotes…

Subscribe free
Market Fieldnotes12 minFreeGBC Research

How to compare ETFs: holdings, overlap, costs and the KID

In short

How to compare ETFs: check holdings and overlap (the sum of the lower weights across two funds), top-ten concentration, expense ratio, tracking difference versus the index, spread, premium or discount to NAV, and domicile. The cheaper fund depends on the holding period: a 0.07% expense ratio with a 0.30% spread breaks even with 0.20% and 0.04% at two years. From the EU, retail investors usually can’t buy US ETFs, which lack a KID.

Since January 1, 2018, investors who try to buy a New York-listed ETF from an account in the European Union have often been told by their broker that the product isn’t available. The fund exists and trades every day. What stops the order is the EU’s PRIIPs Regulation, in force since that date: anyone selling or advising on a packaged investment product to a retail investor must first hand over a standardized short document, the KID.

US issuers generally don’t produce one. In 2021 a Member of the European Parliament put the issue to the Commission in a written question: according to the text, since 2018 ordinary EU investors cannot invest in US ETFs, partly because the KID requires future performance scenarios that US rules don’t allow issuers to publish.

So investors in the EU end up comparing different ETFs from the ones American websites talk about: UCITS funds, domiciled for example in Ireland or Luxembourg, that often track the same indexes under their own rules, costs and taxes. The first test in any comparison becomes a question nobody investing from the United States ever asks: can I buy it?

How to compare ETFs, starting with what they hold

An ETF is a fund whose shares you buy and sell on an exchange like a stock. Its name suggests a theme; its holdings and index rules tell you what you own. Two funds with different names can hold many of the same companies, and two funds on the same theme can interpret it in very different ways.

Before the charts, read three things. The first is the full holdings list, with its date: it is a snapshot, and an index rebalance or a month of market moves can change it. The second is the index methodology, the rules for how a stock gets in or out. The third is the weighting scheme: a market-cap-weighted index gives more room to the largest companies, an equal-weighted one gives each the same slice, and from the same list of names they build different portfolios.

Read the stated objective as well. Funds that promise a multiple of the index (2x, 3x) or its inverse do so over a predetermined period. Over horizons longer than that period the result can drift far from the expected multiple, for the same reason a 10% gain followed by a 10% loss doesn’t bring you back to where you started, as our guide to drawdown math explains. They need a separate reading and stay out of this comparison.

How do you calculate the overlap between two ETFs?

The overlap between two funds is the sum, stock by stock, of the lower of the two weights. Take two hypothetical funds with four large holdings each, three of them shared.

Hypothetical holdings, as % of each fund’s assets
StockFund AFund BLower weight
X20%30%20%
Y15%10%10%
Z10%0%0%
W5%8%5%
V0%12%0%
Other stocks, not shared50%40%0%
Overlap35%

Overlap tells you how alike the two funds are. How much a stock weighs in your portfolio depends on how much you put in each. With $1,000 per fund, X is worth $200 + $300 = $500 out of $2,000, or 25%. Owning two funds left the concentration intact, with two different names in front of it.

Shift the allocation to $1,500 in Fund A and $500 in Fund B. Exposure to X becomes $300 + $150 = $450, or 22.5%. A simple average of the two weights, (20% + 30%) ÷ 2, would still say 25%: without the dollar amounts the math is wrong. The same check applies between an ETF and the stocks you already own, as our guide to correlation and hidden exposure shows.

Two ETFs, one stock at 25% of the portfolioTwo ETFs, one stock at 25% of the portfolio. Combined exposure to each stock with $2,000 split between Fund A and Fund BFIG. 1 · WEIGHTED OVERLAPGB.CAPITALTwo ETFs, one stock at 25% of the portfolioCombined exposure to each stock with $2,000 split between Fund A and Fund B$1,000 + $1,000$1,500 in Fund A + $500 in Fund BStock X25%22.5%Stock Y12.5%13.75%Stock Z5%7.5%Stock W6.5%5.75%Stock V6%3%Hypothetical example. Fund A weights: X 20%, Y 15%, Z 10%, W 5%. Fund B: X 30%, Y 10%, W 8%, V 12%.Overlap between the two funds: 35%.
Figure 1 Two funds with different names can leave a single stock at a quarter of the portfolio.

Try it on your own funds. Take the two ETFs with the largest weight in your account, download their holdings from the issuer’s website and, before doing the math, write down how much you think they overlap. Then add up the lower weights across all shared holdings and compare your guess with the result. If you use only the top ten shared stocks, label the result as partial overlap.

How much does an ETF really cost: expense ratio, spread and commissions

The expense ratio (in Europe, TER, total expense ratio) is the annual running cost, expressed as a percentage of the fund’s average net assets. The fund pays it out of its own assets, as Investor.gov explains, so it lowers the value of every share without ever showing up on your statement. On a constant $10,000 base, a 0.20% expense ratio comes to $20 a year and a 0.40% one to $40.

The expense ratio leaves out two costs you pay on every trade: the broker’s commission and the spread, the gap between the price you can buy at and the price you can sell at. Buying at the ask and selling at the bid, a round trip costs roughly one full spread. Our guides to volume, liquidity and spread and to trading costs, currency included, break them down one by one.

Now compare two hypothetical funds on the same index, with $10,000 and identical commissions, which therefore drop out. Fund A has a 0.07% expense ratio but a 0.30% spread; Fund B has a 0.20% expense ratio and a 0.04% spread.

Cumulative cost on $10,000: expense ratio × years + one full spread (hypothetical example)
Holding periodFund A (0.07% + 0.30%)Fund B (0.20% + 0.04%)
3 months$31.75$9.00
1 year$37$24
2 years$44$44
5 years$65$104
10 years$100$204

You find the break-even by dividing the spread difference by the expense-ratio difference: (0.30 − 0.04) ÷ (0.20 − 0.07) = 2 years. The two-year break-even assumes a constant invested amount, unchanged fees and spreads, and no investment returns. Recalculate it if those assumptions change.

The cheaper fund depends on how long you hold itThe cheaper fund depends on how long you hold it. Cumulative cost on $10,000: annual expense ratio plus one full spread to buy and sellFIG. 2 · COST AND HOLDING PERIODGB.CAPITALThe cheaper fund depends on how long you hold itCumulative cost on $10,000: annual expense ratio plus one full spread to buy and sellFund A: 0.07% expense ratio, 0.30% spreadFund B: 0.20% expense ratio, 0.04% spread$0$50$100$150$200$25002 yrs4 yrs6 yrs8 yrs10 yrsYEARS HELDBreak-even at 2 years: $44 eachA: $100B: $204Hypothetical example. Constant $10,000 base, no returns, identical commissions left out.
Figure 2 Under two years the tight spread wins; beyond that the low expense ratio does.

If you swing trade an ETF and hold it for a few weeks, you mostly pay the spread; if you accumulate for ten years, you mostly pay the expense ratio. On funds with wide spreads, a limit order sets the highest price you are willing to pay. A better execution price depends on the limit and available liquidity, and the order may not fill.

What is the difference between tracking difference and tracking error?

Tracking difference is the gap between the fund’s return and the index’s return over a period, usually a year. Tracking error, in the definition used by ESMA’s guidelines, is the volatility of the difference between the return of the index-tracking fund and the return of the index. The first tells you how far behind or ahead you ended up; the second how steady that gap was.

If the index returns +10.00% in a year and the fund +9.85%, the tracking difference is −0.15 percentage points. That shortfall is smaller than the 0.20% expense ratio in this hypothetical example. That can happen, because dividend taxes, transaction costs and any securities-lending income push in opposite directions. For index-tracking UCITS funds, ESMA’s guidelines require the annual and half-yearly reports to state the tracking error at period end and to explain the annual tracking difference. Read over three years, it is the closest number to the cost you actually bore.

How do you judge an ETF’s liquidity?

An ETF has two prices: the value of its assets per share, the NAV, and its market price, which can sit above it (a premium) or below it (a discount). If NAV is $50.00 and the shares trade at $50.10, you are paying a 0.2% premium.

In the United States, ETFs operating under SEC Rule 6c-11, which excludes leveraged and inverse funds, must post on their website the prior day’s NAV, market price and premium or discount, a table of premiums and discounts over the last year, and the median bid-ask spread over the last thirty days. For European funds the data available varies by issuer, and your broker’s order book remains the most direct source.

Daily share volume tells only part of the story. New shares can be created or redeemed by authorized participants, so an ETF’s liquidity also depends on the liquidity of what it holds: a thinly traded fund on an index of large companies can have tight spreads even with little trading in its own shares.

Domicile, UCITS and the KID: what changes if you invest from Europe?

Domicile is the country where the fund is registered, and it can differ from the exchange you buy it on and from the currency it trades in. For a retail investor in the EU it often decides access, through the KID: since 2018 a KID has been required, and since 2023 UCITS funds use the PRIIPs KID too. A UCITS ETF is recognizable by its name, which under ESMA’s guidelines must include the label “UCITS ETF.”

Domicile also affects how dividends from the underlying stocks are taxed and the fund’s income policy, distributing or accumulating. Those are tax questions that depend on your situation, to be checked in the prospectus and with whoever advises you.

Then there is currency. A euro-listed ETF holding US stocks exposes you to the dollar as if you had bought them directly: the trading currency changes the price on your screen, and the currency risk stays unless the fund states that it hedges it (hedged share classes).

Same index, two rulebooksSame index, two rulebooks. What changes when you invest from a European accountFIG. 3 · DOMICILE AND RULESGB.CAPITALSame index, two rulebooksWhat changes when you invest from a European accountUS-DOMICILED ETFEUROPEAN UCITS ETFBuyable by an EU retailinvestorUsually not: without a KID thebroker cannot sell itYesShort-form documentSEC prospectus; usually no KIDPRIIPs KID, required for UCITStoo since 2023Liquidity data on thewebsitePrior-day NAV, price, premium ordiscount; 30-day median spreadVaries by issuer: check thesite and your broker’s orderbookGap versus the indexDepends on the fund’s documentsAnnual tracking difference andtracking error in the annualreportNameNo EU identifierMust include “UCITS ETF”Sources: PRIIPs Regulation (CSSF), European Parliament question E-004745/2021, SEC Rule 6c-11, ESMAguidelines 2012/832. Not tax or legal advice.
Figure 3 Two funds on the same index can live under different rules, and for investors in the EU the first row decides everything.

These checks help you pick the vehicle. Deciding how much weight each one gets in your portfolio is a separate step: portfolio construction is one of the topics of the Growth Investing course we are preparing.

Summing lower weights for only the ten largest shared holdings produces partial overlap, not whole-fund overlap. For the total, extend the rows to every holding, match identifiers and assign zero where one fund lacks a security. Use holdings lists from the same date and label the result as complete or restricted to the largest positions. The difference between +10.00% and +9.85% is −0.15 percentage points.

Frequently asked questions

How do you choose between two ETFs on the same index?

Compare expense ratio, three-year tracking difference, spread and premium or discount to NAV, then domicile and structure (replication, distributing or accumulating, currency hedging). Work out the total cost over your holding period: for a short hold the spread dominates, for a long one the expense ratio does.

What is ETF overlap and how do you calculate it?

It is the share of the portfolio two funds have in common: for each stock held by both, take the lower weight and add them up. Two funds holding X at 20% and 30%, Y at 15% and 10%, and W at 5% and 8% overlap by 35%.

Why can’t I buy US ETFs in Europe?

Since 2018 the EU’s PRIIPs Regulation has required anyone selling an investment product to a retail investor to provide a KID first, and US issuers generally don’t produce one. For many indexes there are UCITS ETFs domiciled in Europe that track them and do have a KID.

What is the difference between expense ratio and tracking difference?

The expense ratio is the annual running cost the fund declares. Tracking difference is the actual gap between the fund’s return and the index’s, and it can be larger or smaller than the expense ratio because of taxes, transaction costs and securities lending.

What does UCITS ETF mean?

It marks an ETF harmonized under the EU’s UCITS fund rules. ESMA’s guidelines require the label “UCITS ETF” in the name and documents, and since 2023 these funds provide retail investors with the PRIIPs KID.

Does a euro-listed ETF remove currency risk?

No. If the fund holds US stocks, its value follows the dollar even when the shares are quoted in euros. Currency risk only shrinks with a share class that states it is hedged, which carries its own costs.

Sources and further reading

Related research
Bid-ask spread, volume and liquidity: how to read the costMarket Fieldnotes · 05.10.2026Portfolio diversification: correlation and hidden exposureMarket Fieldnotes · 05.10.2026Debt maturity schedule: maturity wall and interest riskMarket Fieldnotes · 05.10.2026How to import a TC2000 workspace and check it worksMarket Fieldnotes · 28.10.2026Trading costs: commissions, spread and currency, explainedMarket Fieldnotes · 05.10.2026 Full archive →
FREE · EVERY SUNDAY

Get the next Radar
before Monday’s open.

The first name, the reasoning, and our public research.

FREE · EVERY SUNDAYGet the watchlist