Stop-limit order vs stop order: what each one guarantees
In short
A market order seeks execution at available prices. A limit order sets a price boundary but may remain unfilled. Once triggered, a stop becomes a market order and a stop-limit becomes a limit order. If a stock gaps from $50 to $44, a $47 sell stop may fill around $44 if buyers are available there. A 47/46 sell stop-limit cannot fill below $46.
On Monday, August 24, 2015, SPY opened 5.2% below Friday’s close, and by 9:35 in New York it was down 7.8%. SPY is an ETF, an exchange-traded fund that tracks the S&P 500. In the first minutes, IVV, another ETF tracking the same index with the same stocks inside, fell more than 20%. By about 9:43 it had recovered all of it.
The two funds held the same stocks and for a few minutes sat more than twelve points apart, on a morning with 1,278 automatic trading pauses across 471 securities. A sell stop on IVV knew nothing about the value of the stocks inside the fund; once touched, it became a market order and sold to whatever buyer was there, at whatever price.
Five years earlier it had happened in one afternoon. On May 6, 2010, between 2:40 and 3:00 p.m., US indexes, already down more than 4%, dropped another 5 to 6% within minutes and then bounced back. The SEC and CFTC counted more than 20,000 trades in over 300 securities executed at prices more than 60% away from where they had been moments before, some at a penny. The SEC later wrote that many retail stop orders, triggered by the decline, had tried to sell immediately as buyers pulled back, and got very poor executions.
The price you type into a stop order is a trigger. It tells your broker when to act; the price is set by whoever is on the other side at that moment. If you trade your own account, that difference is measured in dollars, usually on the worst day. We write our exit level down before we enter, but the order type decides what happens at that level when the market jumps.
How do the four main stock order types work?
The everyday orders come down to four, and to a choice between two priorities, price and execution. A market order seeks immediate execution at available prices, without guaranteeing completion during a halt or when counterparties are absent, and leaves the price open. A limit order sets the worst price you will accept and leaves open the chance that the trade never happens. Stop and stop-limit orders sit dormant until price touches a level, then turn into one or the other.
| Order | When it acts | Priority or price constraint | What can go wrong |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market | Right away | Execution at available prices | A worse price than the one on screen |
| Limit | Right away, at your price or better | The price | No fill, or only a partial one |
| Stop (stop-loss) | When price touches the stop | Seeking an exit once triggered | A fill far from the stop in a gap |
| Stop-limit | When price touches the stop | A minimum price to sell, a maximum to buy | No fill if price jumps past the limit |
A market order prioritizes execution without fixing the price. A limit sets a price boundary but can remain unfilled. Choose according to the risk you can accept if the price moves before execution.
What is a market order, and why can the price differ?
A market order asks to buy or sell right now, at the prices available. The big number on your platform is the price of the last trade, which is already history. To buy, you pay the price at which someone is willing to sell, the ask; to sell, you receive the price at which someone is willing to buy, the bid. Each price is good for a certain number of shares, and the list of all those offers is called the order book.
Hypothetically, the last trade is at $50.00. The book shows 30 shares offered at $50.02, another 50 at $50.10 and more at $50.25. A market order for 100 shares buys 30 at $50.02, 50 at $50.10 and the last 20 at $50.25. The average price is $50.106, and you spend $5,010.60 instead of the $5,000 you had in mind. On a heavily traded stock the difference might be a cent; on a small cap at the open, much more. Estimating it in advance means knowing how to read volume, liquidity and the bid-ask spread.
FINRA, the body that oversees US brokers, warns that with a market order you might not get the price you saw, especially in fast-moving markets. That gap is a real cost even at zero commission, as we explain in the guide to trading costs.
What is a limit order, and why can it go unfilled?
A buy limit at $49 can fill at $49 or lower; a sell limit at $52, at $52 or higher. If nobody accepts your price, the order waits. If someone accepts it for part of the size, you get a partial fill. You ask for 100 shares, you get 40, and the other 60 remain an open order.
A limit also works as a ceiling. If, in the example above, you send a buy limit at $50.10, you get 30 shares at $50.02 and 50 at $50.10, an average of $50.07, while the last 20 wait in line instead of chasing the price up to $50.25. A limit at or through the current price is called a marketable limit order. Its cost never shows up on your statement, because it is the trade you didn’t make, the stock that runs to $55 without you.
How does a stop order (stop-loss) work?
A stop order sits dormant until price touches the level you chose, then becomes a market order. A sell stop, the classic stop-loss, sits below the current price and closes a position that is going wrong. A buy stop sits above it and is used to enter when a stock breaks through a level, or to cover a short sale.
Two details vary from broker to broker. The first is the price that triggers the stop. According to the SEC, some brokers use only the last sale, others use bid and ask quotes. The second is timing. A stop can be triggered by a move lasting a few minutes and filled well below where the stock closes that evening, which is why it belongs at the level where your idea is proven wrong, and that level is rarely a few cents from the price. Ask your broker whether stops work in extended hours.
Before you read on, try answering this. You own 100 shares bought at $50 with a sell stop at $47. The stock closes at $50, reports disappointing earnings that evening and opens at $44 the next morning. At what price do you sell? There are three possibilities: at $47, near $44, or not at all. Pick one before moving to the next section.
What is the difference between a stop order and a stop-limit order?
With a plain stop, the right answer is near $44. The first trade of the morning prints at $44, below your $47. The stop triggers, becomes a market order and sells to the buyers who are there, around $44. You had planned to lose $300, $3 on 100 shares. You lose $600, twice as much. The stop doesn’t create a buyer at $47, because between the $50 close and the $44 open no trade took place.
With a stop-limit order, stop at $47 and limit at $46, the right answer is “you don’t sell.” The stop triggers as before, but this time it becomes a sell limit at $46, which can sell at $46 or higher and never below. With buyers at $44 the order waits, and you are still holding 100 shares.
If the price returns to $46 while the order is live, the stop-limit may fill at $46 or better, depending on available buyers and queue priority. A full fill at $46 would realize a $400 loss. If the stock instead falls to $41 without a fill, the open loss is $900 and the position remains exposed.
A stop prioritizes getting out at the available price, without guaranteeing that a counterparty will be present; a stop-limit buys a minimum price and pays for it with the risk of staying in. The distance between stop and limit is the slippage you accept, which with 47 and 46 comes to $1 a share and no more. In May 2016 FINRA reminded brokers that a stop price does not lock in the execution price, and encouraged them to consider prominent warnings and making stop-limit the default order type.
Neither order protects you from a gap. If an earnings report can move the stock 12% overnight, the defense that works is size, a position size calculated so that even a loss twice the plan stays bearable. We deal with earnings risk specifically in the guide to earnings gaps and overnight risk.
Accepted, filled, partially filled: what does each order status mean?
“Accepted” means the instruction has entered the broker’s system, and says nothing yet about whether you bought or sold anything. “Partially filled” means part of the quantity went through and the rest is still an open order, on the same terms. “Filled” and “canceled” are final states, and only the broker’s confirmation tells you which one happened.
Go back to the buy limit for 100 shares at $49, filled for 40. You ask to cancel the remaining 60. The request takes a short but real time to reach the market, and if someone sells at $49 meanwhile, the 60 fill first. The expensive mistake comes next. You think you hold 40 shares, send a new order for 60 “to complete it” and end up with 160. Before you fix or repeat an order, check the position and the status of open orders, and log the price you asked for next to the price you got in your trading journal.
Use a simulated account to inspect the order states your platform supports. Place a limit away from the current price, change it and request cancellation. A partial fill may not occur, and a simulator’s execution model can differ from live trading. Check the final status before entering another order.
How long does an order last: day, GTC and extended hours
A day order expires at the close if it hasn’t filled. A GTC (good-till-canceled) order stays active until it fills or you cancel it. Each broker has its own rules on maximum duration, extended sessions, splits and dividends. FINRA points out that news released outside regular hours can move the price at the next open, which is how a forgotten GTC stop ends up in the $50 to $44 example.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a stop-loss and a stop-limit order?
A stop-loss, or stop order, becomes a market order once triggered and seeks execution at available prices, which can be far from the stop. A sell stop-limit cannot fill below its limit and may remain unfilled. The stop favors execution, while the stop-limit imposes a price boundary.
Does a stop-loss order guarantee the exit price?
No. SEC and FINRA distinguish the stop price from the execution price. After activation, the order seeks available buyers. In the hypothetical gap from $50 to $44, a $47 sell stop could fill around $44 if sufficient bids are available there. The opening price alone does not establish the fill.
What happens to a stop-limit order if the stock opens below the limit?
The stop triggers and the order becomes a sell limit, which stays unfilled until price comes back to the limit or above. Meanwhile the position stays open and the loss can grow. If price returns to the limit while the order is live, it can sell at that price or better, provided available quantity and queue priority allow a fill.
What is a partial fill?
It is when only part of the quantity you ordered finds a counterparty at your price. If you ask for 100 shares with a $49 limit and 40 fill, you hold 40 shares and still have an open order for 60, which can fill later on the same terms.
Is a market order or a limit order better?
Consider the cost of a worse execution price alongside the risk of missing the trade. Liquidity, order size, volatility and timing affect the result. A limit, including a marketable limit, imposes a price boundary without guaranteeing execution. A market order seeks execution without that boundary.
Do stop orders work in pre-market and after-hours trading?
It depends on the broker. Rules for extended sessions vary, and according to the SEC so does the price that triggers a stop, the last sale at some firms and quotes at others. Check the terms in writing before relying on a stop outside regular hours.
Sources and further reading
- SEC, Division of Economic and Risk Analysis: Equity Market Volatility on August 24, 2015 (December 2015)
- CFTC and SEC: Findings Regarding the Market Events of May 6, 2010 (September 2010)
- SEC, Division of Trading and Markets: memo to the Equity Market Structure Advisory Committee (January 2016)
- Investor.gov (SEC): Stop, Stop-Limit, and Trailing Stop Orders
- FINRA: Order types
- FINRA: Regulatory Notice 16-19 on stop orders in volatile markets (May 2016)
