Bid-ask spread, volume and liquidity: how to read the cost
In short
The bid-ask spread is the gap between the best price a buyer is offering (the bid) and the best price a seller is asking (the ask). With a $20.00 bid and a $20.10 ask it is $0.10, or 0.50% of the midpoint, and buying 100 shares and selling them right back costs $10. Volume tells you how much traded during the day; liquidity tells you how many shares you can move right now without pushing the price. You need all three, because they measure different things.
Until 2001, US stocks were quoted in fractions of a dollar. From 1997 the minimum price increment on the NYSE and Nasdaq was one sixteenth, or 6.25 cents, and by April 2001 the switch to decimals was complete. In its 2012 report to Congress, the SEC cites a study of that switch. For large companies, the average quoted spread fell from 11 cents to 6 on the NYSE and from 10 cents to 4 on Nasdaq.
For small companies it changed far less, from about 23 cents to 18 on the NYSE and from 26 to 23 on Nasdaq, and for the smallest Nasdaq stocks the decline wasn’t even statistically significant. Everyone got the same rule, yet the cost of getting in and out collapsed for widely traded stocks and barely moved for the rest. Spreads are set by how many buyers and sellers are actually in the book at that moment.
Spread affects the prices you receive on entry and exit, rather than appearing as a separate charge on your statement. The $10 example is one immediate round trip, not a full spread charged twice. To assess execution, check the spread, trading volume and displayed depth together.
What is the bid-ask spread, and how do you calculate it?
The bid is the highest price a buyer is showing at that moment. The ask (or offer) is the lowest price a seller is showing. The spread is the difference between the two. An immediately executable buy fills at the ask and a sell at the bid, provided enough shares are available there. The midpoint is a useful reference for comparing those prices.
A hypothetical example. Bid $20.00, ask $20.10. The spread is $0.10 and the midpoint $20.05. As a percentage, 0.10 ÷ 20.05 = 0.50%. If you buy 100 shares at $20.10 and sell them right back at $20.00, you lose $10 before any commission, assuming those prices and quantities are still there. You pay it even when your broker charges nothing, which is why the spread is the first item in our guide to trading costs.
When you compare two stocks, state the denominator. The same spread is 0.50% of the bid, 0.4975% of the ask and 0.4988% of the midpoint. The differences are small, but if you switch conventions from one stock to the next, the comparison stops meaning anything. We use the midpoint, and so does the spreadsheet further down.
What is the difference between volume and liquidity?
Volume counts the shares that changed hands over a period, usually the day. Liquidity is your ability to buy or sell the size you need, right now, without moving the price much. The first is history, the second a snapshot. They usually travel together, because a widely traded stock tends to have a thicker book, but the day’s volume doesn’t tell you how many shares are on the ask at this moment. Trading may have bunched up around a headline at 9:35, and by 3:00 p.m. the book can be thin.
Volume also needs the right unit. Two stocks that each trade 2 million shares a day can represent very different amounts. At a constant price of $3 the traded value is $6 million, and at $150 it is $300 million. Dollar volume sums the value of the trades. Multiplying share volume by one reference price gives an estimate when prices vary. Compare that estimate with your position size. Today’s volume against the average of recent weeks shows how trading activity has changed.
Try this before you read on. You need to buy $10,000 of a stock and later sell it. Stock A costs $50, has a $0.05 spread and trades 300,000 shares a day. Stock B costs $8, has a $0.02 spread and trades 5 million shares a day. Which one costs you less? Go with your gut, then do the math.
A costs less. With A you buy 200 shares and the spread costs you $10, or 0.10%. With B you buy 1,250 shares and the spread costs you $25, or 0.25%. B trades almost seventeen times as many shares and more than twice as many dollars, and it still costs you two and a half times as much. B’s two cents looked smaller than A’s five until you divided them by the price.
How do you read the order book, and why does the average price change?
The order book lists resting orders level by level. Every bid and ask price comes with a number of shares. Displayed depth is the quantity visible at each price level, including the best quotes. Suppose the ask shows 30 shares at $20.10 and another 70 at $20.20. If you buy 100 shares at market, you take 30 at $20.10 ($603) and 70 at $20.20 ($1,414). You spend $2,017, an average price of $20.17.
The best ask was $20.10, but only 30 shares could use it. Against the $20.05 midpoint you paid 12 cents more per share, or 0.60%. The example is static and ignores hidden orders and changes in the book during execution, which in real life can make the result better or worse.
A limit order at $20.10 would stop you paying $20.20, but it could leave you with 30 shares and 70 still to buy. A cheaper fill on 30 shares is a different position from a 100-share purchase, with different risk. How each order type behaves against a thin book is covered in our guide to market, limit, stop and stop-limit orders.
Why does the same spread weigh differently?
A ten-cent spread is 5% of a $2 stock, 0.5% of a $20 stock and 0.05% of a $200 stock. On $10,000 bought and sold right back, that is $500, $50 and $5. The same number of cents weighs a hundred times more on the $2 stock than on the $200 one.
Compare the spread with planned risk. If the actual purchase price is $20.10 and the assumed actual exit is $19.10, the $1 distance already includes the spread reflected in those prices. A $0.10 spread equals 10% of that distance; against a $0.20 distance it equals 50%. Do not add it again. If the plan instead starts from the midpoint or last trade, estimate executable prices, commissions and slippage before calculating the position size.
When does the spread widen: the open, news and extended hours
Spread and depth change through the day. In the minutes after the open the book is still forming, and a headline or an earnings report can reshape it within seconds, as we describe in the guide to earnings gaps.
Outside regular hours, spreads can widen and available size can shrink. The SEC lists wider spreads, less volume in some stocks and prices that may not reflect the regular session among the risks of after-hours trading. FINRA notes that an order may fill only partly or not at all, and that some brokers accept only limit orders. The NBBO protection described for regular hours does not extend to these sessions. Brokers still have best-execution obligations outside regular hours.
What to record to measure the real cost of your fills
For every trade, real or simulated, save the bid, ask, intended size, quote time and fill price. Use a consistent reference, such as the midpoint when you send the order. For a buy, calculate (fill price − midpoint) ÷ midpoint. For a sell, use (midpoint − fill price) ÷ midpoint, so a worse fill has a positive cost in both cases. This difference includes the spread paid relative to the midpoint and any further price movement. Log partial fills and delayed quotes separately. Twenty trades give you an initial sample to examine, not a reliable cost estimate for every stock and time slot.
The same exercise exposes a limit of simulations. In a simulated account, fills can happen at prices and sizes that were never in the real book. A screen full of active tickers is no proof that every order will go through at the price you see.
Also check quantity available at the best quote: a tight spread for ten shares does not imply the same cost for a thousand. The order-book snapshot applies to that instant. Prices can change while an order is being transmitted. Keep the confirmation’s time, quantity and prices to distinguish the quoted spread from the execution difference actually paid.
Frequently asked questions
What is a bid-ask spread in stocks?
It is the difference between the best price someone will pay (the bid) and the best price someone will sell at (the ask) at a given moment. Buying right away means paying the ask and selling right away means getting the bid, so the spread is the cost of an immediate round trip, before commissions.
How do you calculate the spread as a percentage?
Divide the difference between ask and bid by the midpoint. With a $20.00 bid and a $20.10 ask, the midpoint is $20.05 and the spread is 0.10 ÷ 20.05 = 0.50%. Always use the same denominator when you compare stocks.
Does high volume mean a stock is liquid?
The two usually go together, but not always. Volume tells you how much traded during the day, while liquidity is about how many shares you can find right now at the best prices. A low-priced stock can trade millions of shares and still have a higher percentage spread than an expensive stock trading a few hundred thousand.
Why are spreads wider in pre-market and after-hours trading?
Because there are fewer participants and fewer trades. The SEC lists wider spreads, less volume and prices that may not reflect the regular session among the risks of after-hours trading. FINRA notes that some brokers accept only limit orders. The NBBO protection described for regular hours does not extend to these sessions, while brokers still have best-execution obligations.
What is an order book?
It is the list of resting orders in a stock, with bid and ask prices and the number of shares at each level. It shows whether your size can fill at the best price or will have to climb to the next levels, at a higher average price.
Is the spread a cost even with zero-commission trading?
Yes. Buying at the ask and selling at the bid means paying the spread on every round trip, whatever the commission. With a 10-cent spread on a $20 stock, 100 shares bought and sold right back cost $10 before commissions.
