Trading costs: commissions, spread and currency, explained
In short
Trading costs are everything between the move on the chart and the result in your account: spread and execution quality (already inside your fill prices), commissions, currency conversion, the exchange-rate effect, fixed costs such as market data, and taxes. A hundred shares bought at $20 and sold at $20.20 make $20 gross and $12 after $8 in commissions. In a euro account, if the exchange rate moves from 1.10 to 1.12, that becomes −€14.61 before costs.
On December 17, 2020, Robinhood, the US broker that grew on commission-free trading, agreed to pay $65 million to settle SEC charges. According to the SEC, between 2015 and late 2018 it had failed to tell customers that its largest source of revenue was the payments it received from trading firms for sending them customer orders, known as payment for order flow.
Those payments, unusually high, had a flip side. Customer orders were executed at prices worse than those available elsewhere, and the SEC calculated that, even after the savings on commissions, customers had lost a total of $34.1 million. The commission was zero, and the cost had moved into the execution price, where a statement never shows it as a separate line.
If you trade your own account, the costs you see are only part of the costs you pay. And if you trade US stocks from an account in euros, pounds or any other currency, the exchange rate can outweigh all the other items combined. The quickest way to see them is to line them up on a single trade, from the chart to the statement.
What are the costs of trading, from chart to account?
The first layer is execution. You buy at the ask and sell at the bid, so the spread and the quality of your fill are already inside the prices you got. The second is the broker’s commissions, per order or per share. The third, if your account currency differs from the stock’s, is the conversion fee the broker keeps every time it changes euros into dollars and back. The fourth is the exchange-rate effect, which depends on the market and can work for you or against you. Then come recurring costs (data, platform, margin interest) and, last, taxes, which depend on your country and account type.
A complete hypothetical case. The account is in euros. On the chart the stock goes from $19.98 to $20.22 in midpoint prices: on 100 shares that is $24, or €21.82 at a rate of 1.10. You buy at $20.00 and sell at $20.20, because you pay the ask and receive the bid, and the gross drops to $20. You pay $4 commission per order. Between purchase and sale the exchange rate moves from 1.10 to 1.12 dollars per euro, and the broker keeps 0.25% on each conversion.
The result is −€30.87 before taxes. The spread costs €3.64, commissions €7.27, conversion €9.05, and the exchange rate on its own €32.73. The stock did exactly what you hoped and the account lost money.
How much do commissions weigh on a trade?
On 100 shares bought at $20 and sold at $20.20, the gross gain is $20. With a $4 commission to buy and another $4 to sell, $12 is left. Had the gain been 5 cents a share, the $5 gross would have turned into a $3 loss with the same commissions. A fixed commission weighs little on a large trade and a lot on a small one.
To estimate a break-even move before a trade, assume an unchanged exchange rate and start from a reference price. Add three pieces: commissions divided by the position value, the spread as a percentage, and the round-trip currency conversion. On a $2,000 position with $8 in commissions, a 0.2% spread and 0.25% conversion each way, that is 0.4% + 0.2% + 0.5% = 1.1%. In a dollar account the conversion disappears and the threshold drops to 0.6%.
You pay costs on every trade, winners and losers alike. If your average gain per trade is 1% and costs take 1.1%, the strategy loses money even when it seems to work on the chart, which is why costs belong in your win rate and risk-reward math from the start. The more trades you make, the longer the bill gets, and that is one of the concrete differences between swing trading, day trading and investing.
Should you subtract the spread from your result?
It depends on where you start. If you calculate the result from your fill prices, the spread is already in there. Buying at $20.00 you paid the ask, selling at $20.20 you received the bid. Subtracting it again would count it twice. If instead you estimate a trade before placing it, starting from the last price or the midpoint, you have to add it, along with the slippage a large order suffers as it climbs the book. How to measure the spread as a percentage is covered in our guide to volume, liquidity and the bid-ask spread.
The Robinhood case says something else, too. Execution quality is a cost that depends on where and how your order is filled, and it appears in no commission schedule. A first benchmark is the midpoint when you sent the order. Execution quality also includes whether and how quickly the order fills. A limit order sets the worst acceptable price if it executes, but may remain unfilled.
How much does currency conversion cost on US stocks?
Before you read the math, try to guess it. You buy $2,000 of stock when one euro is worth 1.10 dollars and sell it for $2,020 when one euro is worth 1.12. The stock rose 1%. Did you make or lose money in euros, and roughly how much?
You lost. The purchase cost you 2,000 ÷ 1.10 = €1,818.18, and the sale returns 2,020 ÷ 1.12 = €1,803.57. That is −€14.61 before commissions and conversion fees, because the stock rose 1% while the exchange rate moved 1.8% the wrong way. The euro strengthened, so each dollar you receive buys fewer euros.
These are two different effects, and they belong on separate lines. The conversion fee is a charge the broker takes on every exchange, and it always works against you. The exchange-rate move is market risk and cuts both ways. Had the rate fallen to 1.08, the same $2,020 would have been worth €1,870.37, a €52.19 gain. Holding dollars in the account between trades reduces the number of conversions, but leaves you exposed to the exchange rate the whole time. Whatever you choose, measure the result in euros with a consistent method and reconcile it with your statement.
In Europe, the MiFID II rules require investment firms, when part of the costs is in a foreign currency, to state the currency and the conversion rates and costs applied. They must also send an annual personalized report of all costs incurred, with an illustration of the cumulative effect of costs on return (Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, Article 50). If you have never opened yours, it is the first document to ask your broker for.
How do you count fixed costs: data, platform, interest?
Say you pay $30 a month for market data. With 10 closed trades that month, an equal split puts $3 on each, and the example’s net drops from $12 to $9. With 2 trades the share rises to $15 and that $12 becomes −$3. How you allocate is a choice in your own records and leaves the $30 actually paid unchanged. Traders who trade rarely on expensive subscriptions find out this way that their break-even is much higher than they thought.
Margin interest, platform fees and any custody charges go in the same column, each with its source. Taxes on gains depend on your country and account type and can’t be estimated with a rate picked at random. The calculator below has a row for them, to fill in from your statement or your tax adviser. Gross gain, commissions, currency costs and the share of fixed costs then go into your trading journal trade by trade, so every gap between the chart and the account has an explanation.
B18 estimates break-even with an unchanged exchange rate and approximate percentage costs; it is not the rise that guarantees a nonnegative euro result. For exact currency-adjusted break-even, set B17 to zero and solve for B3 using the broker’s exchange rates and charges. Enter a positive trade count in B9. Allocation of fixed costs is undefined with zero trades.
Frequently asked questions
What are the costs of online trading?
The main items are the spread and execution quality, broker commissions, currency conversion fees if your account is in another currency, recurring costs such as data and platform fees, any margin interest, and taxes. On top of those comes the exchange-rate effect, which depends on the market and can change your result more than all the other items.
Does commission-free trading mean free trading?
No. You still pay the spread, and execution quality can be worse. In 2020 the SEC charged Robinhood, which paid $65 million to settle, and calculated that its customers, even counting the commission savings, had lost $34.1 million to inferior execution prices.
How much does currency conversion cost when buying US stocks from a euro account?
There are two effects. The conversion fee is a percentage the broker keeps on every exchange, going in and coming out. The exchange-rate move is market risk: buying at 1.10 and selling at 1.12 dollars per euro turns a $20 gain on $2,000 into a €14.61 loss before costs.
How do you calculate the net profit on a trade?
Start from your fill prices, which already include the spread, subtract actual commissions, convert purchase and sale at the rates actually applied, and deduct conversion fees and your share of fixed costs. Taxes come last, under the rules of your country and account.
Should you keep dollars in your account between trades?
It cuts the number of conversions and therefore their cost, but it leaves you exposed to the exchange rate for as long as the dollars sit there. The choice depends on how often you trade in dollars and how much currency risk you are willing to carry. Either way, measure your result in euros with the same method every time.
How much do costs matter over the long run?
They compound year after year. In an SEC example, $100,000 growing 4% a year for 20 years ends at about $208,000 with 0.25% in annual costs and about $179,000 with 1%. In active trading, record the costs of every trade alongside recurring fees. The total depends on how often and how much you trade.
Sources and further reading
- SEC: SEC Charges Robinhood Financial With Misleading Customers About Revenue Sources and Failing to Satisfy Duty of Best Execution (December 2020)
- EUR-Lex: Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, Article 50 on information about costs and charges
- Investor.gov (SEC): How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio
- FINRA: Order types
