Interest rates and stocks: the mechanisms and 2022
In short
The link between interest rates and stocks runs through four channels: the rate used to discount future cash flows, the cost of corporate debt, demand from customers who buy on credit, and margins when inflation pushes up costs. The first hits growth stocks hardest: if the discount rate rises from 8% to 10%, $100 due in one year loses 1.8% of its value and $100 due in twenty years loses 30.7%. In 2022 the Fed raised rates by 4.25 points: S&P 500 −19.4%, Nasdaq −33.1%.
At the start of 2022, the federal funds rate, the benchmark the Federal Reserve uses to steer every other US interest rate, sat between 0 and 0.25%. By December it sat between 4.25% and 4.50%. In between came seven hikes, four of them 0.75 points each, back to back, from June to November. The Fed was chasing inflation that hit 9.1% over twelve months in June, the highest reading since November 1981.
By year-end the S&P 500 had lost 19.4%. The Nasdaq Composite, heavy with technology and growth companies, had lost 33.1%. The Dow Jones Industrial Average, thirty large companies with far less technology than the Nasdaq, had lost 8.8%. Energy, the only sector that rose, had gained 59%. The same shock, over the same months, produced results more than twenty points apart from one index to another.
Part of that gap comes down to a calculator operation, discounting future cash flows, and it is the same operation that will decide how much the next rate cycle weighs on the stocks you own. Nobody knows when that cycle will come or whether it will bring hikes or cuts. The mechanism, on the other hand, can be learned today.
Interest rates and stocks: what happened in 2022?
The cycle began in March 2022 with a 0.25-point hike, after the emergency cuts of March 2020, and ended in July 2023 with the eleventh hike, leaving the rate between 5.25% and 5.50%. In sixteen months, the cost of very short-term money rose by 5.25 points.
For stocks, though, the long-term rate matters most. The yield on the 10-year Treasury, the US government’s ten-year bond, is the risk-free benchmark rate that almost every valuation model starts from. It went from an average of 1.47% in December 2021 to 3.98% in October 2022: two and a half points in ten months. Stock buyers build their minimum required return on top of that number, and when it rises, the price they are willing to pay for each dollar of future earnings changes.
How do interest rates change what a stock is worth?
The theoretical value of a stock is the sum of the cash flows the company will generate in the future, each brought back to today with a discount rate: the minimum return investors demand for waiting and for bearing the risk, which is the government bond yield plus an equity risk premium. For a single cash flow, present value = cash flow ÷ (1 + rate)^years.
Take $100 arriving one year from now. At an 8% discount rate it is worth $92.59 today; at 10% it is worth $90.91, so the two-point rise takes off 1.8%. The same $100 ten years out is worth $46.32 at 8% and $38.55 at 10%, 16.8% less. Thirty years out it is worth $9.94 and $5.73, 42.3% less.
The rate rose by the same amount for every cash flow, and its effect compounds with every year of waiting. So the useful question when rates rise is about the timing of a company’s cash flows: how much of its value arrives in the next few years, and how much ten or twenty years out.
Why are growth stocks more sensitive to interest rates?
Before you read the table, try answering. Two hypothetical companies are each worth about $100 a share at an 8% discount rate. The first, a mature business, generates $6 of cash per share in the first future year and grows 2% a year. The second, a growth company, generates $2, grows 15% a year for ten years and 3.5% after that. If the rate rises to 10%, how much does each lose? Write down your two estimates.
The calculation uses a two-stage model. For the first ten years you discount each cash flow with the formula above. From year eleven onward you fold everything into a terminal value, equal to the year-11 cash flow divided by the gap between the discount rate and growth, and discount it back ten years. For the mature company, which always grows 2%, the math collapses to $6 ÷ (8% − 2%) = $100.
| Item | Mature | Growth |
|---|---|---|
| Cash per share, year 1 | $6.00 | $2.00 |
| Growth, years 1–10 | 2% | 15% |
| Growth after year 10 | 2% | 3.5% |
| Value at 8% | $100.00 | $99.92 |
| Share of value beyond year 10 | 56.5% | 75.0% |
| Value at 10% | $75.00 | $65.58 |
| Change | −25.0% | −34.4% |
The growth company loses 34.4%, the mature one 25%. Three quarters of the growth company’s value arrives after year ten, against just over half for the mature one, and those distant cash flows take the heaviest discount. There is a second effect too. In the terminal value the denominator is the gap between the rate and growth, and for the growth company that gap is smaller. Two extra points of rate take it from 4.5 to 6.5 points, 44% wider, while for the mature company it goes from 6 to 8, 33% wider, so the growth company’s terminal value shrinks more.
The mechanism works both ways. At a 6% rate the mature company would be worth $150 and the growth company $190.63. It is the same math that lifts long-duration stocks when rates fall, and the reason a portfolio full of growth stocks is, whether you meant it or not, a bet on rates. When you value a stock with multiples, the price-to-earnings ratio hides the same effect. A high P/E is another way of saying the market is paying today for earnings far in the future.
How do rates hit corporate debt and customers?
Floating-rate debt
In a hypothetical example, a company has $100 million of floating-rate debt at 4%: it pays $4 million a year in interest. If the rate rises to 6%, it pays $6 million. With $20 million of operating income, interest coverage, operating income divided by interest, falls from 5 times to 3.3 times, and $2 million of profit disappears without anything changing in the business. Fixed-rate debt stays protected until it matures or is refinanced, which is why maturity dates matter as much as the amount; you will find them in the debt footnote of the annual report, as explained in our guide to company debt and its maturities.
Customers who buy on credit
Higher rates also make customers’ borrowing more expensive. Companies selling homes, cars, machinery or durable goods bought with financing see their customers’ monthly payments rise before the price of the product changes at all. A business selling low-cost necessities feels this channel far less.
How does inflation change company margins?
Inflation pushes up both selling prices and costs, but rarely by the same amount or in the same months. In a hypothetical example a company sells a product for $100 at an operating cost of $80: profit is $20 and the margin 20%. The next year the price rises to $110 and the cost to $92. Revenue grows 10%, profit falls to $18 and the margin to 16.4%. A report with rising revenue can hide a company earning less, and higher nominal revenue doesn’t tell you whether more units were sold.
Two things matter. The first is pricing power, the ability to pass higher costs on to customers without losing them, the clearest sign of an economic moat. The second is timing: if costs rise right away and price lists only adjust when contracts renew, the quarters in between show squeezed margins. The relationship between revenue and operating margin during high-inflation periods says more than any statement from management.
Which sectors react most to interest rates?
Each sector is exposed mainly to one channel. The table describes mechanisms; within each sector there are companies with very different balance sheets.
| Sector | Main channel | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Technology and growth | Discount rate: value concentrated far in the future | Share of value beyond 10 years, cash on hand |
| Utilities and listed real estate | Heavy debt; dividends competing with government bonds | Debt maturities, floating-rate share |
| Banks | Interest margin between loans and deposits | Deposit costs, losses on securities held |
| Homes, autos, durable goods | Demand from customers who buy on credit | Orders, financing rates offered |
| Energy and materials | Inflation: selling prices tied to commodities | Realized prices, extraction costs |
| Consumer staples | Margins: steady demand, costs to pass on | Gross margin in high-inflation quarters |
If your portfolio holds ten growth stocks from different sectors, the channel is still a single one, and the diversification is more apparent than real. How to measure it is covered in our guide to correlation and hidden exposures.
Why can stocks rise while the Fed is hiking?
Prices build in expectations. When the Fed announces a decision, the market reacts to the gap between what it decided, along with its guidance about the future, and what was expected. A hike priced in for weeks can leave the indexes flat; the same hike delivered with a tougher tone than expected can push them down.
2022 shows it clearly. The S&P 500’s decline began on January 3 and ended on October 12. On that day the rate sat between 3% and 3.25%: there were still 2.25 points of hikes to come and nine months until the last one, in July 2023. Anyone waiting for the end of the hikes to start buying again arrived after the low was already behind them, and nobody, at the time, could know it was the low. That is why our decisions start from what the market is doing.
In the mature-company model, $6 is the first future year’s cash flow: that convention makes 6 ÷ (8% − 2%) equal 100. If it were the just-completed year’s cash flow, the numerator would be 6 × 1.02. To value equity, use cash flows to shareholders and the cost of equity; whole-company cash flows require WACC followed by a net-debt adjustment.
Frequently asked questions
Why do stocks fall when interest rates rise?
Because a stock’s value is the sum of its future cash flows discounted to today, and a higher rate lowers the present value of those cash flows. Higher rates also raise companies’ borrowing costs and make customers’ credit-financed spending more expensive. How far a stock falls also depends on how much of the hike was already expected.
Which stocks are most sensitive to interest rates?
Those whose value depends on cash flows far in the future, such as growth companies that generate little cash today, and those with a lot of floating-rate debt or debt due for refinancing soon. In this guide’s example, a rise in the discount rate from 8% to 10% takes 34.4% off a growth company and 25% off a mature one, both worth about $100.
How does inflation affect stocks?
Through margins and through rates. If costs rise faster than selling prices, profit falls even as revenue grows, and high inflation pushes the central bank to raise rates. Companies with pricing power defend their margins better.
What is a stock’s discount rate?
It is the minimum return an investor demands for owning that stock, usually the government bond yield plus a risk premium. It brings future cash flows back to today: $100 due in ten years is worth $46.32 at an 8% rate and $38.55 at 10%.
How much did the Fed raise rates in 2022?
By 4.25 points over seven decisions, taking the fed funds target range from 0–0.25% to 4.25–4.50% in December 2022. Four more hikes in 2023 ended the cycle in July 2023 at 5.25–5.50%.
Do banks make money when interest rates rise?
They can, if the rates they charge on loans rise faster than the rates they pay on deposits, because their interest margin widens. At the same time, the fixed-rate securities they hold lose value and customers may move deposits to higher-yielding options, so the effect depends on each bank’s balance sheet.
Sources and further reading
- Federal Reserve: history of the federal funds target range
- BLS: consumer prices up 9.1% over the year ended June 2022
- CNBC: stocks end Wall Street’s worst year since 2008
- FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis: 10-year Treasury yield, monthly average
- PBS NewsHour (AP): the S&P 500 bear market from January 3 to October 12, 2022
- Federal Reserve: how monetary policy affects the economy
